{ "article_slug": "formation-movement-in-godot", "artifact": "Standalone Godot formation movement and authored release/reform proof", "checks": [ { "id": "line_slot_count_and_centering", "observed": { "count": 8, "first": "(-140.0, 0.0)", "last": "(140.0, 0.0)", "sum_x": 0.0 }, "passed": true }, { "id": "column_slot_spacing", "observed": { "offsets": [ "(0.0, 0.0)", "(0.0, -32.0)", "(0.0, -64.0)", "(0.0, -96.0)", "(0.0, -128.0)" ], "spacing": 32.0 }, "passed": true }, { "id": "all_layout_slot_ids_are_unique", "observed": { "column": 8, "line": 8, "wedge": 8 }, "passed": true }, { "id": "local_to_world_rotation_matches_four_facing_oracles", "observed": { "observed": [ "(80.0, 110.0)", "(110.0, 120.0)", "(120.0, 90.0)", "(90.0, 80.0)" ] }, "passed": true }, { "id": "anchor_skips_zero_length_segments", "observed": { "finished": false, "forward": "(1.0, 0.0)", "position": "(5.0, 0.0)" }, "passed": true }, { "id": "anchor_forward_and_final_facing_are_deterministic", "observed": { "corner": { "finished": false, "forward": "(0.0, 1.0)", "position": "(10.0, 0.5)" }, "finish": { "finished": true, "forward": "(-1.0, 0.0)", "position": "(10.0, 10.0)" } }, "passed": true }, { "id": "corner_rotation_preserves_slot_assignments", "observed": { "after": { "unit_00": "front", "unit_01": "left_01", "unit_02": "right_01", "unit_03": "left_02", "unit_04": "right_02" }, "before": { "unit_00": "front", "unit_01": "left_01", "unit_02": "right_01", "unit_03": "left_02", "unit_04": "right_02" }, "forward_after_corner": "(0.0, 1.0)" }, "passed": true }, { "id": "assignment_is_bijective", "observed": { "assignments": { "unit_00": "front", "unit_01": "left_01", "unit_02": "right_01", "unit_03": "left_02", "unit_04": "right_02", "unit_05": "left_03" }, "unique_slots": 6 }, "passed": true }, { "id": "assignment_is_deterministic_under_input_shuffle", "observed": { "first": { "unit_00": "front", "unit_01": "left_01", "unit_02": "right_01", "unit_03": "left_02", "unit_04": "right_02", "unit_05": "left_03" }, "second": { "unit_00": "front", "unit_01": "left_01", "unit_02": "right_01", "unit_03": "left_02", "unit_04": "right_02", "unit_05": "left_03" } }, "passed": true }, { "id": "valid_previous_assignments_are_preserved", "observed": { "assignments": { "unit_00": "left_01", "unit_01": "front", "unit_02": "right_01", "unit_03": "left_02" } }, "passed": true }, { "id": "duplicate_member_id_is_rejected", "observed": { "code": "DUPLICATE_MEMBER_ID", "member_id": "same", "ok": false }, "passed": true }, { "id": "duplicate_slot_id_is_rejected", "observed": { "code": "DUPLICATE_SLOT_ID", "ok": false, "slot_id": "same" }, "passed": true }, { "id": "membership_removal_preserves_survivor_slots_and_anchor", "observed": { "after": { "unit_00": "front", "unit_01": "left_01", "unit_02": "right_01" }, "anchor": "(45.0, 60.0)", "before": { "unit_00": "front", "unit_01": "left_01", "unit_02": "right_01", "unit_03": "left_02" } }, "passed": true }, { "id": "same_value_and_small_drift_target_writes_are_suppressed", "observed": { "first": true, "same": false, "small": false }, "passed": true }, { "id": "explicit_invalidation_bypasses_deadband", "observed": { "forced": true, "invalidated": true }, "passed": true }, { "id": "map_revision_revalidates_without_forced_equal_write", "observed": { "current_revision": 8, "endpoint_revalidation_required": true, "equal_target_write_requested": false, "validated_revision": 7 }, "passed": true }, { "id": "target_writes_respect_repath_governor_budget", "observed": { "budget": 3, "dispatched": 3, "remaining": 5 }, "passed": true }, { "id": "missing_agent_disables_member_motion", "observed": { "binding_result": { "code": "AGENT_MISSING", "ok": false }, "expected_push_error": "ERROR: AGENT_MISSING", "motion_blocked": true, "physics_processing_disabled": true }, "passed": true }, { "id": "agent_parent_not_character_body_is_rejected", "observed": { "binding_result": { "code": "AGENT_PARENT_NOT_CHARACTER_BODY", "ok": false }, "expected_push_error": "ERROR: AGENT_PARENT_NOT_CHARACTER_BODY", "motion_blocked": true, "physics_processing_disabled": true }, "passed": true }, { "id": "agent_parent_mismatch_disables_member_motion", "observed": { "binding_result": { "code": "AGENT_PARENT_MISMATCH", "ok": false }, "expected_push_error": "ERROR: AGENT_PARENT_MISMATCH", "motion_blocked": true, "physics_processing_disabled": true }, "passed": true }, { "id": "second_path_update_owner_same_tick_is_rejected", "observed": { "first": { "code": "OK", "ok": true, "owner": "VALIDATING", "physics_tick": 42 }, "next_tick": { "code": "OK", "ok": true, "owner": "MOVEMENT", "physics_tick": 43 }, "second": { "code": "PATH_UPDATE_ALREADY_OWNED", "first_owner": "VALIDATING", "ok": false, "physics_tick": 42, "rejected_owner": "MOVEMENT" } }, "passed": true }, { "id": "invalid_map_blocks_validation", "observed": { "code": "MAP_UNAVAILABLE", "ok": false, "requested_slot": "(0.0, 0.0)" }, "passed": true }, { "id": "wide_zone_reaches_moving_formed", "observed": { "history": [ "FORMING", "MOVING_FORMED" ], "state": "MOVING_FORMED" }, "passed": true }, { "id": "release_reform_hysteresis_prevents_flapping", "observed": { "history": [ "FORMING", "MOVING_FORMED", "RELEASED", "REFORMING" ], "hold_ticks": 6, "state": "REFORMING" }, "passed": true }, { "id": "required_and_optional_straggler_policies_are_distinct", "observed": { "optional_member_excluded_from_required_error_scale": 1.0, "required_member_error_scale": 0.0 }, "passed": true }, { "id": "reformation_arrival_latches_until_new_order", "observed": { "arrived": true, "latched": true, "state_after_new_order_reset": "FORMING" }, "passed": true }, { "id": "every_frame_counterfactual_integrates_live_member_ticks", "observed": { "completed": true, "completed_snapshot": { "actual_target_writes_by_state": { "ARRIVED": 1, "MOVING_FORMED": 2, "REFORMING": 1, "RELEASED": 1 }, "actual_target_writes_run": 5, "counterfactual_physics_frames": 5, "every_frame_target_writes": 37, "every_frame_target_writes_by_state": { "ARRIVED": 7, "MOVING_FORMED": 8, "REFORMING": 7, "RELEASED": 15 }, "run_first_physics_frame": 100, "run_last_physics_frame": 104, "run_physics_frames_contiguous": true, "run_physics_ticks": 5, "run_physics_ticks_by_state": { "ARRIVED": 1, "MOVING_FORMED": 1, "REFORMING": 1, "RELEASED": 2 }, "target_writes_avoided": 32, "target_writes_if_every_physics_frame": 37, "write_measurement_active": false, "write_measurement_complete": true, "write_measurement_order_id": 77 }, "passed": true, "queue_guarded": true, "reset_snapshot": { "actual_target_writes_by_state": {}, "actual_target_writes_run": 0, "counterfactual_physics_frames": 0, "every_frame_target_writes": 0, "every_frame_target_writes_by_state": {}, "run_first_physics_frame": -1, "run_last_physics_frame": -1, "run_physics_frames_contiguous": true, "run_physics_ticks": 0, "run_physics_ticks_by_state": {}, "target_writes_avoided": 0, "target_writes_if_every_physics_frame": 0, "write_measurement_active": false, "write_measurement_complete": false, "write_measurement_order_id": 0 } }, "passed": true }, { "id": "target_mismatch_and_short_endpoint_are_typed", "observed": { "final_position": "(698.0, 240.0)", "mismatch_code": "TARGET_MISMATCH", "passed": true, "requested": "(640.0, 240.0)", "slot_error": 58.0, "unreachable_code": "SLOT_UNREACHABLE" }, "passed": true }, { "id": "requested_final_and_slot_error_are_preserved", "observed": { "final_position": "(698.0, 240.0)", "mismatch_code": "TARGET_MISMATCH", "passed": true, "requested": "(640.0, 240.0)", "slot_error": 58.0, "unreachable_code": "SLOT_UNREACHABLE" }, "passed": true }, { "id": "navigation_finished_without_slot_reach_does_not_arrive", "observed": { "endpoint_code": "SLOT_UNREACHABLE", "required_slot_reached": false, "state": "MOVING_FORMED" }, "passed": true }, { "id": "runtime_write_measurement_uses_one_contiguous_completed_order_window", "observed": { "actual_target_writes_by_state": { "ARRIVED": 8, "MOVING_FORMED": 136, "REFORMING": 80, "RELEASED": 72 }, "actual_target_writes_run": 296, "counterfactual_physics_frames": 551, "every_frame_target_writes": 4408, "every_frame_target_writes_by_state": { "ARRIVED": 16, "MOVING_FORMED": 1352, "REFORMING": 984, "RELEASED": 2056 }, "run_first_physics_frame": 16, "run_last_physics_frame": 566, "run_physics_frames_contiguous": true, "run_physics_ticks": 551, "run_physics_ticks_by_state": { "ARRIVED": 2, "MOVING_FORMED": 169, "REFORMING": 123, "RELEASED": 257 }, "target_writes_avoided": 4112, "target_writes_if_every_physics_frame": 4408, "write_measurement_active": false, "write_measurement_complete": true, "write_measurement_order_id": 1 }, "passed": true }, { "id": "deadbanded_target_writes_are_below_same_run_every_frame_counterfactual", "observed": { "actual_target_writes_by_state": { "ARRIVED": 8, "MOVING_FORMED": 136, "REFORMING": 80, "RELEASED": 72 }, "actual_target_writes_run": 296, "counterfactual_physics_frames": 551, "every_frame_target_writes": 4408, "every_frame_target_writes_by_state": { "ARRIVED": 16, "MOVING_FORMED": 1352, "REFORMING": 984, "RELEASED": 2056 }, "run_first_physics_frame": 16, "run_last_physics_frame": 566, "run_physics_frames_contiguous": true, "run_physics_ticks": 551, "run_physics_ticks_by_state": { "ARRIVED": 2, "MOVING_FORMED": 169, "REFORMING": 123, "RELEASED": 257 }, "target_writes_avoided": 4112, "target_writes_if_every_physics_frame": 4408, "write_measurement_active": false, "write_measurement_complete": true, "write_measurement_order_id": 1 }, "passed": true }, { "id": "validating_and_arrived_states_ignore_stale_safe_velocity", "observed": { "arrived": { "after": "(967.7352, 483.9997)", "before": "(967.7352, 483.9997)", "passed": true, "running": true, "state": "ARRIVED", "velocity": "(0.0, 0.0)" }, "inactive": { "after": "(128.8, 484.0)", "before": "(128.8, 484.0)", "passed": true, "running": false, "state": "FORMING", "velocity": "(0.0, 0.0)" } }, "passed": true }, { "id": "narrow_gate_makes_progress_and_reforms_with_assignments_preserved", "observed": { "actual_target_writes_run": 296, "assignment_signature": "unit_07:left_04|unit_06:left_03|unit_05:left_02|unit_04:left_01|unit_02:right_01|unit_03:front|unit_01:right_02|unit_00:right_03", "assignment_unique": true, "desired_velocities": { "unit_00": "(220.0, 0.006344)", "unit_01": "(220.0, 0.000492)", "unit_02": "(220.0, 0.0)", "unit_03": "(220.0, 0.0)", "unit_04": "(220.0, 0.0)", "unit_05": "(220.0, -0.000511)", "unit_06": "(220.0, -0.001053)", "unit_07": "(220.0, -0.037139)" }, "formation_revision": 1, "governor_queue_depth": 0, "history": [ "FORMING", "MOVING_FORMED", "RELEASED", "REFORMING", "MOVING_FORMED", "ARRIVED" ], "history_in_order": true, "map_iteration": 1, "map_region_count": 1, "maximum_required_error": 187.133560180664, "member_distance": 838.935180664063, "nav_polygon_count": 7, "next_path_read_count": 2204, "order_id": 1, "passed": true, "path_changed_count": 292, "safe_velocities": { "unit_00": "(0.0, 0.0)", "unit_01": "(0.0, 0.0)", "unit_02": "(0.0, 0.0)", "unit_03": "(0.0, 0.0)", "unit_04": "(0.0, 0.0)", "unit_05": "(0.0, 0.0)", "unit_06": "(0.0, 0.0)", "unit_07": "(0.0, 0.0)" }, "state": "ARRIVED", "state_assignment_signatures": { "ARRIVED": "unit_07:left_04|unit_06:left_03|unit_05:left_02|unit_04:left_01|unit_02:right_01|unit_03:front|unit_01:right_02|unit_00:right_03", "FORMING": "unit_07:left_04|unit_06:left_03|unit_05:left_02|unit_04:left_01|unit_02:right_01|unit_03:front|unit_01:right_02|unit_00:right_03", "MOVING_FORMED": "unit_07:left_04|unit_06:left_03|unit_05:left_02|unit_04:left_01|unit_02:right_01|unit_03:front|unit_01:right_02|unit_00:right_03", "REFORMING": "unit_07:left_04|unit_06:left_03|unit_05:left_02|unit_04:left_01|unit_02:right_01|unit_03:front|unit_01:right_02|unit_00:right_03", "RELEASED": "unit_07:left_04|unit_06:left_03|unit_05:left_02|unit_04:left_01|unit_02:right_01|unit_03:front|unit_01:right_02|unit_00:right_03" }, "target_write_count": 304, "target_writes_if_every_physics_frame": 4408, "transition_log": [ { "physics_tick": 16, "reason": "ORDER_ACCEPTED", "state": "MOVING_FORMED" }, { "physics_tick": 131, "reason": "AUTHORED_RELEASE_ZONE_ENTERED", "state": "RELEASED" }, { "physics_tick": 388, "reason": "OPEN_SPACE_HOLD_COMPLETED", "state": "REFORMING" }, { "physics_tick": 511, "reason": "REQUIRED_MEMBERS_REACQUIRED_SLOTS", "state": "MOVING_FORMED" }, { "physics_tick": 565, "reason": "STABLE_AGGREGATE_ARRIVAL", "state": "ARRIVED" } ], "write_measurement": { "actual_target_writes_by_state": { "ARRIVED": 8, "MOVING_FORMED": 136, "REFORMING": 80, "RELEASED": 72 }, "actual_target_writes_run": 296, "counterfactual_physics_frames": 551, "every_frame_target_writes": 4408, "every_frame_target_writes_by_state": { "ARRIVED": 16, "MOVING_FORMED": 1352, "REFORMING": 984, "RELEASED": 2056 }, "run_first_physics_frame": 16, "run_last_physics_frame": 566, "run_physics_frames_contiguous": true, "run_physics_ticks": 551, "run_physics_ticks_by_state": { "ARRIVED": 2, "MOVING_FORMED": 169, "REFORMING": 123, "RELEASED": 257 }, "target_writes_avoided": 4112, "target_writes_if_every_physics_frame": 4408, "write_measurement_active": false, "write_measurement_complete": true, "write_measurement_order_id": 1 } }, "passed": true }, { "id": "packaged_project_rerun_matches_named_checks", "passed": true, "observed": { "workspace_named_checks": 34, "extracted_named_checks": 34, "check_ids_match": true, "scene_smoke_passed": true, "source_manifest_entries": 10, "source_manifest_hashes_match": true, "expected_wrapper_error_allowlist": [ "ERROR: AGENT_MISSING", "ERROR: AGENT_PARENT_NOT_CHARACTER_BODY", "ERROR: AGENT_PARENT_MISMATCH" ], "wrapper_errors_seen_once_in_workspace": true, "wrapper_errors_seen_once_in_extracted_package": true, "engine": "4.7.1-stable (official)" } } ], "engine": { "build": "official", "hash": "a13da4feb8d8aefc283c3763d33a2f170a18d541", "hex": 263937, "major": 4, "minor": 7, "patch": 1, "status": "stable", "string": "4.7.1-stable (official)", "timestamp": 0 }, "failed": [], "failed_count": 0, "measurement_scope": "Correctness, deterministic policy, runtime integration, visible state transitions, and a same-run arithmetic target-write counterfactual only; no frame-time, repath-cost, throughput, or scalability claim.", "passed": true, "passed_count": 35, "proof_boundary": { "authored_geometry": "The narrow gate uses explicit release and reform zones; it is not a clearance detector.", "not_verified": "Automatic bottleneck detection, optimal target assignment, complete MAPF, general deadlock freedom, large-crowd performance, or subjective motion quality.", "product_scope": "This is a standalone article artifact, not a released PathForge formation API.", "verified_here": "Local-space layouts, virtual-anchor progression, stable greedy assignment, path-update ownership, deadbanded target writes, a same-order sum-of-live-member-ticks counterfactual, typed endpoint evidence, all three fail-closed FormationMember2D binding branches, authored gate release/reform, pacing policy, aggregate arrival, and an eight-agent scene smoke." }, "scene_smoke": { "eight_characterbody_navigationagent_members": true, "navigation_ready": true, "passed": true, "runtime_report": { "actual_target_writes_run": 296, "assignment_signature": "unit_07:left_04|unit_06:left_03|unit_05:left_02|unit_04:left_01|unit_02:right_01|unit_03:front|unit_01:right_02|unit_00:right_03", "assignment_unique": true, "desired_velocities": { "unit_00": "(220.0, 0.006344)", "unit_01": "(220.0, 0.000492)", "unit_02": "(220.0, 0.0)", "unit_03": "(220.0, 0.0)", "unit_04": "(220.0, 0.0)", "unit_05": "(220.0, -0.000511)", "unit_06": "(220.0, -0.001053)", "unit_07": "(220.0, -0.037139)" }, "formation_revision": 1, "governor_queue_depth": 0, "history": [ "FORMING", "MOVING_FORMED", "RELEASED", "REFORMING", "MOVING_FORMED", "ARRIVED" ], "history_in_order": true, "map_iteration": 1, "map_region_count": 1, "maximum_required_error": 187.133560180664, "member_distance": 838.935180664063, "nav_polygon_count": 7, "next_path_read_count": 2204, "order_id": 1, "passed": true, "path_changed_count": 292, "safe_velocities": { "unit_00": "(0.0, 0.0)", "unit_01": "(0.0, 0.0)", "unit_02": "(0.0, 0.0)", "unit_03": "(0.0, 0.0)", "unit_04": "(0.0, 0.0)", "unit_05": "(0.0, 0.0)", "unit_06": "(0.0, 0.0)", "unit_07": "(0.0, 0.0)" }, "state": "ARRIVED", "state_assignment_signatures": { "ARRIVED": "unit_07:left_04|unit_06:left_03|unit_05:left_02|unit_04:left_01|unit_02:right_01|unit_03:front|unit_01:right_02|unit_00:right_03", "FORMING": "unit_07:left_04|unit_06:left_03|unit_05:left_02|unit_04:left_01|unit_02:right_01|unit_03:front|unit_01:right_02|unit_00:right_03", "MOVING_FORMED": "unit_07:left_04|unit_06:left_03|unit_05:left_02|unit_04:left_01|unit_02:right_01|unit_03:front|unit_01:right_02|unit_00:right_03", "REFORMING": "unit_07:left_04|unit_06:left_03|unit_05:left_02|unit_04:left_01|unit_02:right_01|unit_03:front|unit_01:right_02|unit_00:right_03", "RELEASED": "unit_07:left_04|unit_06:left_03|unit_05:left_02|unit_04:left_01|unit_02:right_01|unit_03:front|unit_01:right_02|unit_00:right_03" }, "target_write_count": 304, "target_writes_if_every_physics_frame": 4408, "transition_log": [ { "physics_tick": 16, "reason": "ORDER_ACCEPTED", "state": "MOVING_FORMED" }, { "physics_tick": 131, "reason": "AUTHORED_RELEASE_ZONE_ENTERED", "state": "RELEASED" }, { "physics_tick": 388, "reason": "OPEN_SPACE_HOLD_COMPLETED", "state": "REFORMING" }, { "physics_tick": 511, "reason": "REQUIRED_MEMBERS_REACQUIRED_SLOTS", "state": "MOVING_FORMED" }, { "physics_tick": 565, "reason": "STABLE_AGGREGATE_ARRIVAL", "state": "ARRIVED" } ], "write_measurement": { "actual_target_writes_by_state": { "ARRIVED": 8, "MOVING_FORMED": 136, "REFORMING": 80, "RELEASED": 72 }, "actual_target_writes_run": 296, "counterfactual_physics_frames": 551, "every_frame_target_writes": 4408, "every_frame_target_writes_by_state": { "ARRIVED": 16, "MOVING_FORMED": 1352, "REFORMING": 984, "RELEASED": 2056 }, "run_first_physics_frame": 16, "run_last_physics_frame": 566, "run_physics_frames_contiguous": true, "run_physics_ticks": 551, "run_physics_ticks_by_state": { "ARRIVED": 2, "MOVING_FORMED": 169, "REFORMING": 123, "RELEASED": 257 }, "target_writes_avoided": 4112, "target_writes_if_every_physics_frame": 4408, "write_measurement_active": false, "write_measurement_complete": true, "write_measurement_order_id": 1 } } }, "schema_version": 1, "verified_at": "2026-08-04T03:23:53", "source_manifest": [ { "path": "export_presets.cfg", "bytes": 1158, "sha256": "46170a9bd48270794e97de43cde3c7bf5436eac04e0988c77d4ea4ae8e8e6231" }, { "path": "LICENSE", "bytes": 1065, "sha256": "8429a4194733f32d64f3447cd65ebc3ae904adc0e92001aa6a7998e77ac5ca0b" }, { "path": "project.godot", "bytes": 672, "sha256": "60e2d9ec8cf7c83982ecfc0de6e4f49474a00b47c008968a13bcdd435d5edc2a" }, { "path": "README.md", "bytes": 2125, "sha256": "21166ae64999f04ea2ceb6ed4e0e7e3ac012339605326c31541b8330e4c2d952" }, { "path": "scenes/articles/formation_movement_demo.tscn", "bytes": 345, "sha256": "280f5787d92726f58e586cbca27f96934429dbd5d04b9cdfc2fd55194dccbbff" }, { "path": "scripts/articles/formation_member_2d.gd", "bytes": 1933, "sha256": "ada802f64f236b0e669530f730b8547514972a308bb576f5c7418ac7e40b1ef5" }, { "path": "scripts/articles/formation_movement_core.gd", "bytes": 12657, "sha256": "9dc1550e6b07e3c872d883980438703768b573a25fcaf7ae5934d5af2f47138d" }, { "path": "scripts/articles/formation_movement_demo.gd", "bytes": 57146, "sha256": "99171ebff3dd323fd1de74c9faf8847a6a970a96aa97dcf2df2097514f4ca008" }, { "path": "scripts/articles/repath_governor.gd", "bytes": 6909, "sha256": "d1a0df1a8673b370b0f6970e217c6245c5769c01b3a4f5366dbe8118f8dabe32" }, { "path": "tools/verify_formation_movement.gd", "bytes": 29018, "sha256": "fe491067624e9cde89225d6eca8cac64fe0cd96477395fdb25a02396f97c787d" } ], "published_files": { "source_zip": { "path": "/downloads/pathforge/formation-movement-in-godot-source.zip", "bytes": 31000, "sha256": "8286767a7ffc5346dc984e7e593b9606e1803a70c40fbdadfbee87f425910b2e" }, "core_source": { "path_in_zip": "scripts/articles/formation_movement_core.gd", "sha256": "9dc1550e6b07e3c872d883980438703768b573a25fcaf7ae5934d5af2f47138d" }, "member_controller_source": { "path_in_zip": "scripts/articles/formation_member_2d.gd", "sha256": "ada802f64f236b0e669530f730b8547514972a308bb576f5c7418ac7e40b1ef5" }, "demo_source": { "path_in_zip": "scripts/articles/formation_movement_demo.gd", "sha256": "99171ebff3dd323fd1de74c9faf8847a6a970a96aa97dcf2df2097514f4ca008" }, "verifier_source": { "path_in_zip": "tools/verify_formation_movement.gd", "sha256": "fe491067624e9cde89225d6eca8cac64fe0cd96477395fdb25a02396f97c787d" } }, "extracted_package_rerun": { "passed": true, "named_check_count": 34, "published_check_count": 35, "check_ids_match": true, "scene_smoke_passed": true, "source_manifest_hashes_match": true, "engine": "4.7.1-stable (official)" } }